ARRANGEMENT IN GREY AND BLACK
by James Abbot McNeill Whistler
1834-1903


Arrangement in Gray and Black: Portrait of the Artist's Mother by James Abbot McNeill Whistler

James A. Whistler was born in Massachusetts. His father, Major George Washington Whistler, who had graduated from West Point, was a civil engineer. His mother Anna McNeill came from an aristocratic southern family. When he was nine the family moved to Russia where his father oversaw the building of the St. Petersburg and Moscow Railroad. Six years later his father died and the family returned to America.

James himself entered West Point, but dropped out in his third year when he failed to pass a chemistry exam. He was later quoted as saying, "Had silicon been a gas I would have been a 'Major-General'."

He worked for a while as a draftsman drawing maps, but he got in trouble for drawing pictures in the margins of the maps. He finally decided to just pursue art, and in 1855 he sailed to Paris. He was to never return to America.

He moved to London. He began to use musical terms to name his paintings; words such as Arrangements, Harmonies, Symphonies, Nocturnes, Notes, and Caprices.

He painted a portrait of Lady Archibald Campbell. It was not a commissioned painting and she and her friends thought it was ugly when it was finished. She didn't want other people to know she was the subject. Whistler assured her he would not call it by her name, but would call it The Yellow Buskin. Little did she know that it would someday become famous.

Once Whistler took a sailing ship for South America. While on board he made some sketches. He gave them to the purser to take back to England for him, but they never arrived. Later he would find out what happened to them. These excerpts are from Recollections and Impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler by Arthur Jerome Eddy, written in 1904. excerpt 1 and excerpt 2

At the Piano was Whistler's first major work. In it we see Whistler's half-sister Deborah and her daughter Annie. The clothing they are wearing is the tradional dress for people in mourning; black for the mother and white for the child. Whistler's father had died ten years earlier, but he doesn't connect the title with anything about the reason for mourning clothes.

The portrait of Lady Meux is of a London socialite Valerie Susan Meux. He painted several portraits of her. The first was Arrangement in Black, No. 5. (See You Tube at the bottom of this page for the Frick presentation of Harmony in Pink and Grey)

His first successful showing in Paris was at an exhibit of independent artists. The painting was called Symphony in White No. 2 . When he painted Symphony in White No. 1 he first titled it The White Girl and then renamed it six years later. People tried to figure out the "meaning" of the painting, but Whistler said it was just a model and there was no other meaning. When he was painting it, in order to dissuade others from reading meaning into the picture which was not there, he told the model to hang her hands down loosely at her sides and not to express emotion in her face . In 1866 he painted Symphony in White No. 3. Whistler's theory was "art for art's sake". There didn't have to be a deeper meaning to his work.


At the Piano by Whistler


At the Piano
1858-59

Enlarged view

Harmony in Pink and Grey - Portrait of Lady Meux by Whistler


Harmony in Pink and Grey
Portrait of Lady Meux

Enlarged view

Symphony in White No. 1 by Whistler


Symphony in White No. 1
The White Girl

Enlarged view

Theodore Duret was an art critic and collector. He was a wealthy man and had a lot of time to pursue his interest in art. Whistler suggested to Duret that he would like to paint him in evening clothes and asked him to get a pink "domino" or cape for an accent in the picture. Duret purchased such a garment from a theater costumer. Whistler worked on this painting for a long time. Read about the portrait. Manet also made a painting of Duret. Which do you like the best?

Trouville is an area on the Normandy coast in France. Whistler's scene shows a deserted beach. You can still find deserted beaches there today, but much of the coastal area is developed into resorts.

After visiting Whistler's studio and viewing the painting of Whistler's mother, Thomas Carlyle asked the artist to paint a portrait of him. Carlyle was a near neighbor. He would patiently pose for long, tedious sittings. When you compare the portrait of Carlyle and the portrait of Whistler's mother you will notice a similar pose and arrangement.

Arrangement in Light Pink and Black - Portrait of Theodore Duret by Whistler


Arrangement in Flesh Colour and Black
Portrait of Theodore Duret

Enlarged view

Harmony in Black and Silver  Trouville by Whistler


Harmony in Black and Silver
Trouville

Enlarged view

Arrangement in Grey and Black - Portrait of Thomas Carlyle by Whistler


Arrangement in Grey and Black
Portrait of Thomas Carlyle

Enlarged view

Whistler studied in Venice for a year or so and made a series of etchings there. He returned to London. Some people ridiculed his work and did not take him seriously as an artist. He wanted to be viewed as a man-about-town. When he was in public, he appeared to be careless and idle, but when he went to work in his studio, he was just the opposite. The Falling Rocket is a close-up of the Battersea Bridge painting. The scene shows a place in London where they had a fireworks display every night.

The critic John Ruskin said this painting looked as if the artist is "flinging a pot of paint in the public's face". Whistler sued him for libel because of his remarks. At one point in the trial the counsel was told he was holding the painting upside-down. When asked how do you know which is the top and which is the bottom, the reply was, "Oh, I don't know; only when I saw it hanging in the Grosvenor Gallery it was the other side up". Whistler won the case, but the small amount of money he recovered from it did not pay the expenses, and he had to declare bankruptcy. The damages were assessed at one farthing. Whistler wore the coin on his chain long afterwards.

He was reluctant to part with the pictures he painted which kept him in trouble financially. He had no children of his own and his paintings were like his children. From Recollections and Impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler excerpt 1 and excerpt 2

Nocturne in Grey and Gold is a snow scene. He painted a second snow scene in 1876 titled Nocturne Trafalgar Square Chelsea Snow

When Whistler painted Nocturne in Blue and Gold he composed the painting of the bridge by memory. He used a technique in which he visited the bridge and studied it, but didn't paint it while he was on the site. If you look closely you will see the fireworks in the background which he painted as The Falling Rocket.

Night in Black and Gold - The Falling Rocket by Whistler

Night in Black and Gold
The Falling Rocket

Enlarged view

Nocturne in Grey and Gold - Snow in Chelsea by Whistler

Nocturne in Grey and Gold
Snow in Chelsea

Enlarged view

Nocturne in Blue and Gold by Whistler

Nocturne in Blue and Gold
Old Battersea Bridge

Enlarged view

Whistler didn't have a watch and didn't care for clocks. Time meant nothing to him. Once when a man said he would meet him at "4:30 precisely", Whistler replied to him, "I have never been able and never shall be able to be anywhere at '4:30 precisely'".

At the World's Exposition in 1893 which was held in Chicago, Whistler's paintings were exhibited in the American section, where they belonged.

In 1888 he married a widow, Beatrix Godwin. Eight years later she died and he was devastated. In 1903 he became ill and died.

The portrait of Whistler's mother, Anna McNeill Whistler, was almost rejected when he first presented it, but it has become a much-loved portrait in America. It was unappreciated for years. At one time it was offered in New York for $1200 and a buyer was not found. When it was exhibited in London it was scorned by the press. It was honored on a postage stamp in 1934 to commemorate Mother's Day. He called the painting An Arrangement in Grey and Black. He didn't want people to just think of it as his mother, but he wanted her to represent all aging mothers. He kept the painting in his home for many years and finally offered it to the French government for the price of 120 pounds.

( Whistler's Mother was on display at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts during the summer of 2006, on loan from the Musee d'Orsay in Paris, France. It is appraised at about $30 million.)

See more paintings by Whistler.



References:

Eddy, Arthur Jerome. Recollections and Impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler, Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1904.
Order

Koval, Anne. Whistler, In His Time, London: Tate Gallery Publications, 1994.
Order

James McNeill Whistler self-portrait 1872

Enlarged view

Work a Jigsaw Puzzle

Online Crossword Puzzle

Online Word Search

Online Word Scramble

Color Picture Online

Memory Puzzle

Online "Who is the Artist?"

Online Multiple-Choice Test

PRINTABLES

Print this webpage

Worksheet

Alphabetical Order

Whistler Crossword Puzzle

Whistler Word Search

Whistler Word Scramble

Picture of Whistler's Mother to print and color.

Print Multiple-Choice Test




26018: Masterpiece of the Month: An Art Appreaciation Program for Grades K-5 Masterpiece of the Month: An Art Appreaciation Program for Grades K-5
By Jennifer Thomas / Teacher Created Resources

Students learn about artistic concepts by looking at great works of art. Follow-up art activities using crayons, chalk, tempera paint, and more reinforce learning.





RESEARCH LINKS


Paintings by Whistler
at Olga's Place

Biography of Whistler
at Olga's Place

James Abbott McNeill Whistler
biography at Web Museum

James Abbott McNeill Whistler
from the ArtChive

Information about Whistler
at Humanities Web

James McNeill Whistler
links at Art Cyclopedia

Whistler
at Wikipedia

Whistler
from the Worldwide Art Gallery

Art History
online interactive art lesson - elementary

Whistler's Mother
coloring page





A LIBRARY OF
ONLINE BOOKS and BOOK PREVIEWS


The Gentle Art of Making Enemies
by James McNeill Whistler (full view) 1890 Order

Preview these Amazon books using the links below.

Whistler
by Haldane Macfall (selected pages)

Whistler's Mother's Cook Book
by Anna Mathilda McNeill Whistler, Margaret F. MacDonald (selected pages)

Whistler, women and fashion
by Margaret F. MacDonald, Susan Grace Galassi, Aileen Ribeiro, Frick Collection (no preview)

Palaces in the Night, Whistler in Venice
by Margaret F. MacDonald, James McNeill Whistler (selected pages)

Recollections and Impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler
by Arthur Jerome Eddy 1904 (full view)





Page Comments

Please leave a comment for this page.

View all Comments


Famous Artists and Biographies in this Series

Index to Famous Paintings & Art Appreciation for Kids

Index to Biographies of Famous People

Reference citations information for these biographies

Famous Artists

Bierstadt

Boughton

Bruegel

Cassatt

Cavallino

Cezanne

Cranach

Curry
Durer
Van Dyck
Van Eyck
De Flandes
Fragonard
Gainsborough
Gauguin
Van Gogh
Goya
Hicks
Holbein
Homer
de Hooch
Hopper
Huguet
Jakuchu
Leutze
Limbourg
Michelangelo
Millet
Monet
Moses
O'Keeffe
Raphael
Rembrandt
Remington
Renoir
Reynolds
Rivera
Rockwell
Rousseau
Rubens
Seurat
Titian
Valazquez
Vermeer
Da Vinci
Whistler
Wyeth
Yani

Presidents of
the United States
George Washington John Adams Thomas Jefferson James Madison James Monroe Andrew Jackson
  Martin Van Buren Abraham Lincoln Theodore Roosevelt Franklin D. Roosevelt Harry S. Truman Dwight D. Eisenhower
  John F. Kennedy Lyndon B. Johnson Jimmy Carter Ronald Reagan Barack Obama Calvin Coolidge
American Patriots Benjamin Franklin Francis Scott Key Deborah Sampson Molly Pitcher
World Leaders Constantine Alexander the Great Winston Churchill Margaret Thatcher
Inventors Alexander Graham Bell Johann Gutenberg Cyrus McCormick The Wright Brothers Henry Ford Thomas A. Edison
  Sequoyah Nikola Tesla Michael Faraday Dean Kamen Jack Kilby Leonardo Da Vinci
  Donald O'Neal
Explorers Christopher Columbus Meriwether Lewis Robert Peary John Muir Matthew Henson Sir Edmund Hillary
  Kit Carson Johnny Appleseed Daniel Boone
Women who made
a difference
Clara Barton Helen Keller Florence Nightingale Joan of Arc Amelia Earhart Annie Oakley
  Susan B. Anthony Elizabeth Keckly Harriet Tubman Anne Frank Eleanor Roosevelt Madam C.J. Walker
  Sadako Sasaki Henrietta Lacks        
Scientists George Washington Carver Sir Isaac Newton Marie Curie Louis Pasteur Albert Einstein Galileo
  Lise Meitner Norman Borlaug Benjamin Banneker
Educators Noah Webster Booker T. Washington Aristotle Mary McLeod Bethune
Physicians Hippocrates Walter Reed Albert Schweitzer
Religious Leaders George Muller Increase Mather
Athletes Lou Gehrig Wilma Rudolph Tiger Woods Michael Phelps
Civil Rights
Leaders
Martin Luther King Rosa Parks Sojourner Truth Frederick Douglass Mary Ann Shadd Cary James Forten
  Gandhi César Chávez William Wilberforce Nelson Mandela
Composers Beethoven Mozart
Authors Laura Ingalls Wilder Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain) Ernest Hemingway Greg Mortenson Phillis Wheatley
Artists John James Audubon Gutzon Borglum Ansel Adams Dale Chihuly Van Gogh Michelangelo
  Rembrandt Grandma Moses Cassatt Renoir Cezanne Rockwell

Art Gallery Famous Paintings Volume 1

Art Gallery Famous Paintings Volume 2

Biographies for Kids - Famous Leaders for Young Readers

Puzzles on these pages courtesy of
Songs of Praise and Armored Penguin

Picture courtesy of The ArtChive Patron Program